We took 2,095 Florida homes, most of them ENERGY STAR homes rated by HERS Raters, and checked each one against the old and new energy codes without changing a thing about the houses. Even among these high-performance homes, about 1 in 6 that pass the Performance path today fail it under the 2026 code. Most of those still pass the ERI path as built. Homes built to standard code will shift in the same direction, but many more of them will fail the Performance path.
Two ways to show a home meets code
Most Florida builders prove a new home meets the energy code in one of two ways:
The Performance path (R405). Software builds a "twin" of your home: the same size and shape, but built exactly to the minimum code. Then it compares how much energy each one uses for heating, cooling and hot water. Under the 2023 code, your home passes if it uses no more than 95% of the twin's energy. Under the 2026 code, the limit drops to 85%. Most Florida homes use this path today.
The ERI path (R406). A HERS Rater gives the home an energy score, where lower is better. The home passes if its score is at or below Florida's target. The target stays the same in 2026, but the method for calculating the score is updated. We've found that most homes see their Florida ERI scores improve when moving to the new code.
So one path got stricter, and the other got a little easier. We wanted to know how much each change matters for real homes.
What we did
We took 2,095 Florida homes modeled in Ekotrope RATER over the last 12 months. We checked each home four ways: the Performance path under the 2023 and 2026 codes, and the ERI path under the 2023 and 2026 codes.
We did not change the homes. The only thing that changed was the code. That shows what the new code does to the same house, which is the question a builder with existing plans needs answered.
Which homes we looked at
Most of these homes were rated by HERS Raters and meet ENERGY STAR requirements, which means they were built to beat code, not just meet it. That puts them at the better end of Florida construction. All of them had their ducts tested. That makes this a best-case view: if these homes lose ground, homes built to the old minimum will lose the same ground from a much smaller starting margin.
What we found
Out of every 100 homes
| 2023 code | 2026 code | Change | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pass the Performance path | 92 | 78 | 14 fewer |
| Pass the ERI path | 69 | 84 | 15 more |
Why did fewer homes pass ERI than Performance under the 2023 code? Most of these homes were designed for the Performance path, so not all of them were built to hit the ERI target. Under the 2026 code, the scoring update pushes most of them under it.
How much room each home has left
Think of it as headroom: how far a home is from failing. Take a home that uses 75% of its twin's energy. Under the old rule (95%), it has 20 points of headroom. Under the new rule (85%), it has 10.
That is close to what we saw across the whole sample:
On the Performance path, every home lost headroom. The typical home went from about 19 points of headroom to about 10.
On the ERI path, no home lost ground. The typical home went from 3 points under the target to 7 points under it.
What this means for homes built to standard code
The direction of each shift applies to standard homes too, because the code changes the same rules for every house. The Performance limit drops 10 points for everyone, and the ERI scoring update applies to everyone.
What differs is the starting point. Compare two homes:
| High-performance home | Standard home | |
|---|---|---|
| Energy use compared with the twin path | 75% | 92% |
| Headroom under the 2023 Rule (95%) | 20 points | 3 points |
| Headroom under the 2026 Rule (85%) | 10 points | -7 points: fails |
Both homes lose the same 10 points. The high-performance home still passes. The standard home fails. So the 1 in 6 failure rate in our sample is a floor, not an estimate for the whole market. Builders who design close to the old 95% line should expect a much larger share of their plans to fail the 2026 Performance path, possibly most of them.
On the ERI path, standard homes also gain from the scoring update. But they start further from the target, so fewer of them will pass as built than in our sample.
What happens to homes that fail the Performance path
Out of every 100 homes in our sample, about 16 pass the Performance path today but fail it under the 2026 code. Of those 16, about 13 pass the ERI path without any changes. Only about 3 fail both paths.
What this means for builders
Rerun your common plans at the new 85% rule before December 31. If you build above code, expect about 1 in 6 to fall short. If you build close to the old minimum, expect far more.
For plans that fall short, you have two options. Upgrade the house to pass the Performance path, or switch that plan to the ERI path.
Ask your energy code consultant to check both paths at once. In Ekotrope RATER, one model gives the Performance and ERI results together.
Limits of this analysis
These homes are not a random sample. Most are ENERGY STAR homes rated by HERS Raters, and all had their ducts tested. The direction of change applies to all homes, but failure rates on the Performance path will be much higher for standard homes.
We didn't change any designs. Real builders will adjust plans, so these numbers show the starting point, not the final outcome.
Scale. We consider the sample representative of the more than 20,000 Florida homes registered with RESNET in 2026.
Frequently asked questions
How much harder is the R405 Performance path in the 2026 Florida code? About 10%. The pass line drops from 95% to 85% of the code-built twin, and the typical home in our sample lost about 9 points of headroom.
Is the ERI path easier in the 2026 Florida code? Yes. The target is the same, but the updated scoring method lowers most homes' scores. No home in our sample got worse.
What share of Florida homes will fail R405 under the 2026 code? About 1 in 6 of the above-code homes in our sample. Homes built to standard code start with less headroom, so a much larger share will fail.