Performance or ERI? How to Choose a Florida Compliance Path by Total Cost

Florida's 2026 energy code takes effect December 31, 2026. Most Florida builders have long used the Performance path (R405) to show a new home meets code. Under the new code, the Energy Rating Index path (ERI, or R406) can cost less for some plans. Compare the full cost of each path for each plan: the energy calc or rating, the field tests and any construction upgrades.

Two ways to show a home meets code

  • The Performance path (R405). Software compares your home with a "twin" of the same size and shape, built to the minimum code. Under the 2023 code, your home passes if its modeled energy use is 95% or less of the twin's (0.95). Under the 2026 code, the limit drops to 85% (0.85).

  • The ERI path (R406). A HERS Rater inspects and tests the home during construction, then gives it an Energy Rating Index score, where lower is better. The home passes at or below Florida's target. The target stays the same in 2026. We’ve found that most homes see a better ERI score using the Florida 2026 ERI.

A third option, the Prescriptive path (R402), sets a minimum for each component. This post compares R405 and ERI.

Why the math changes in 2026

R405 became the default for good reasons. It is the most flexible path, since a builder can trade a weaker spec in one place for a stronger one in another. And many HVAC and insulation contractors include the R405 calc in their services, so builders rarely had to arrange it separately. Two changes in the 2026 code make it worth comparing the paths again:

  • Duct testing becomes required for the R405 pathway. R405 no longer exempts homes from the duct leakage test. The one exception is a home with all ducts and the air handler inside conditioned space, such as an attic with spray foam at the roof deck. More on who needs a test: 2. Duct testing

  • R405 asks for better construction, while ERI often asks for no changes. The R405 threshold drops from 0.95 to 0.85. The ERI target stays the same while most scores improve. In our analysis of 2,095 Florida homes modeled in Ekotrope RATER, 84% passed ERI as built under the 2026 code. Most were ENERGY STAR homes rated by HERS Raters, so homes built to standard code will pass less often.

Compare the full cost

Cost R405 Performance R406 ERI
Energy calc or rating R405 calculation Full ERI rating, including inspections
Field testing Blower door plus duct test (new in 2026) Included in the rating
Construction upgrades Whatever it takes to get from 0.95 to 0.85 Often none

The question for each plan: is the extra cost of a full ERI rating, compared with a calc plus two tests, smaller than the upgrades needed to stay on R405? Count the effort, not just the dollars. ERI adds a rater's inspections and tests to your build schedule. Big upgrades to stay on R405 can mean redrawing plans, changing suppliers or retraining crews. Some HERS Raters in Florida are already moving builders to ERI on that reasoning. The answer depends on your plans, your specs and your rater's pricing.

Sort your plans into four groups

  1. Passes R405 at 0.85 with room to spare. Staying on R405 is likely the lowest cost. Add the duct test to your budget.

  2. Fails R405 but passes ERI. Price the upgrades needed for R405 against the added cost of an ERI rating.

  3. Close to the line on both. Check the specs that matter most first. A lower-wattage ventilation fan or a heat pump water heater may get the home over the line on either path.

  4. Fails both. You need upgrades either way. Pick the path where the cheapest upgrades get you to a pass.

Questions to ask your energy code consultant

  • Can you analyze my plans on every compliance path and give me a report for each?

  • Which of my plans pass R405 at 0.85, and by how much?

  • For plans that fall short, what is the cheapest set of upgrades to pass R405?

  • Do those same plans pass ERI as built?

Your consultant does not need separate models to answer these. Ekotrope RATER produces R405, ERI and Total UA results from the same model, so they can show you every path for each plan at once. Raters who start from Wrightsoft Manual J files can import them directly instead of re-entering the house.

Frequently asked questions

Is the ERI path cheaper than R405 in Florida? It can be, especially for plans that need upgrades to pass R405 at the new 0.85 limit, where a home must use 85% or less of the energy of a code-built twin. Compare the full cost per plan.

What does an ERI rating include that an R405 calc does not? A HERS Rater inspects the home during construction and runs the field tests, then calculates the ERI score.

Can I use different paths for different plans? Yes. The path is chosen per home, so a builder can use R405 for some plans and ERI for others.

Previous
Previous

What’s Changing in the 2026 Florida Energy Code

Next
Next

R405 or ERI: Which Is Easier to Pass Under Florida’s 2026 Code?